Celebrations in Hostage Square in Tel Aviv (JNS) |
The ICC issuing a warrant for his arrest as a war criminal only added fuel to their fire, prompting Israel’s erstwhile international supporters to declare recognition of a Palestinian state — something that Hamas, the 21st-century version of Nazi Germany, openly applauded, thereby considering their Nazi-like atrocities of October 7th two years ago a “success.”
Meanwhile, the left-leaning entertainment industry added its own sense of moral outrage to what Israel has been doing over the past two years. Many A-list actors have advocated boycotting Israel culturally. Not to be outdone, heterodox rabbis - who generally lean strongly to the left - have called Israel’s tactics (read: Netanyahu’s tactics) over the past two years a spiritual catastrophe.
An automatic corollary to vilifying Netanyahu is the vilification of the president. Their hatred for both Netanyahu and Trump is unconditional. No matter what either of them do, it is twisted into negative terms. Any talk of getting the hostages out or ending the war was dismissed as mere bluster because, they said, Trump was all talk and no substance, and Netanyahu had no real interest in ending the war or rescuing the hostages. His only interest was self preservation.
But as I said, I never lost faith in Netanyahu’s stated goals. I believed him. Nor did I believe that the president’s support for Israel was whimsical — dependent on the mood of the moment. I truly believed that both Netanyahu’s and Trump’s motives were genuine.
Well, guess what happened. A deal has been reached between Israel and Hamas that will secure the release of all the hostages. It is estimated that the surviving hostages will be released just before the holiday of Simchas Torah next Monday night. Netanyahu has agreed to pull back his troops to an agreed-upon line in Gaza, and hostage families are beyond overjoyed at this development. Calling for the president to get the Nobel Peace Prize!
The president managed to work out a deal supported by Arab and European leaders, as well as by Netanyahu and Hamas. If I understand correctly, even those Palestinian prisoners to be exchanged for the hostages will not include any of the violent terrorists currently in Israeli prisons. A feat thought impossible just a few weeks ago, even by me. I never thought Hamas would agree. But they did. And the left-leaning critics who were certain Netanyahu would never pull back his troops were wrong too.
And the man who made all this happen is one of the most hated people by the left in American history. I have to wonder how they can possibly spin this into a negative. (But I am absolutely certain that they will.)
I could not be happier about this turn of events. I am overjoyed that the innocent hostages - who were so miserably treated by their Hamas captors - will finally be released after two years of pure torture. Torture that was barely noted by the mainstream, left-leaning media, which chose instead to focus only on blaming Israel for Palestinian suffering, as presented by Hamas’s so-called Health Ministry; its network of sympathetic reporters in Gaza; and a UN with a long history of anti-Israel bias.
I am happy as well for the families of these poor hostages, who will finally get to see their loved ones alive and help nurture them back to health — both physically and mentally. That will surely not be easy.
I am grateful that there will be no more blood shed by soldiers protecting their countrymen in Gaza. And I am also happy at the changed conditions for Israel, which — through the leadership of its prime minister — has managed to all but destroy the capacity of Iranian proxies whose goal was to annihilate the Jews of Israel. They are now a shadow of their former selves. I am glad that the demise of Syria’s dictator, Bashar al-Assad - an ally of Iran - was a byproduct of all this and is no longer the threat it was, and that Iran’s nuclear program has been set back by years. Iran is now focused on restoring itself as a relevant Middle Eastern power instead of pursuing Israel’s destruction.
I doubt that Trump will get the Nobel Peace Prize for this. But if anyone deserves it, Trump does. He has certainly done far more than the last recipient who got one for similar reasons — Barack Obama. But Trump won’t get it. He is too hated by the European nations, including Norway, which awards the Peace Prize. Nor will Netanyahu get any relief from being labeled a war criminal, despite the fact that his accusers have long since abandoned any pretense of impartiality when it comes to Israel.
So it won’t be a perfect ending for either Trump or Netanyahu, both of whom deserve far more credit than they are getting — and certainly not an indictment as a war criminal, as is the case with Netanyahu. But history will remember what he accomplished. They won’t care about a bottle of champagne or a few Cuban cigars he may have received as gifts, or that he made many political enemies. I believe he will instead be remembered as one of the most consequential leaders Israel ever had — right up there with Ben-Gurion and Begin.
As for Trump, the jury is still out on him in terms of domestic policy. But when it comes to foreign policy, he is on the verge of accomplishing what few thought possible: peace in the Middle East. And that will be his legacy.
Trump has accomplished what most would have considered impossible. Yes, he pushed Netanyahu, as well he should. I await mycroft and DSF admitting how wrong they were about Trump, Kushner, the Abraham accords, etc.; however, I am not holding my breathe.
ReplyDeleteDon't be such a cynic, I don't thin Netanyahu would betray his goals if the Trump deal contradicted them. On the contrary. Netanyahu wasn't pushed. He agreed because he saw it as a good deal for Israel. Simple as that.
DeleteThere are those who have emunah bashem, those who have emunah bchachamim, and now see there are those who have emunah bbibi and emunah btrump. Note IIRC R N Lamm wrote that we have emunat chachamim not emunah bchachamim, we believe in what chachamim believed not believe in them
DeleteTrump pushed Bibi to go against what Bibi maintained were essential war goals more than any other Prez since at least Eisenhower has forced Israekli PMs to do what they maintained were essential for Israel.
DeleteI am waiting for those who still believe that Trump will take Israel's side-as a non FNC panel said they give credit to Trump for pushing Bibi to give up his war aims where Biden wouldn't have forced so much. Obviously, Bibi can't admit the truth that Israel accomplished nothing after the first 2-3 months of the war-Hamas not defeated, not sent to exile. Getting hostages back-nice but at what cost forget for secon d if that was purpose of the war to get hostages back-giving back those who will be treated as heroes by the Arab street at the ratio that no other country would accept is not a cause for celebration it is one for mourning. Talmud states as does Rambam that can't pay too much for hostages because of damage to rest of world. Does US ever give ransom in the level that Israel does. Note before Begin Israel would not play this game-now just get more hostages which tells terrorists don't worry about being caught we'll capture some hostages and get you out. BTW this agreement has Israel essentially agreeing to a 2 state solution. Note Trump in both his administrations prevented Israel from annexing new territory in Yehuda vShomrom. Wainting for those afflicted with Trump Devotion Syndrome to admit that their hero has followed basic US policy in Mideast that has been followed for decades
ReplyDeleteHow did I know every word that Mycroft is going to write...
ReplyDeleteI don’t know how anyone can understand anything mycroft says. It is nothing more than a word salad most of the time.
ReplyDeleteLets not forget today is one month from Israel bombing Qatar which got Trump furious at Israel.Of course, Israeli incompetence was shown by such a raid bombing an ally of the US, an ally that has a major airbase of the US and as far as POTUS concerned probably more important a source of a plane that he wants like Bibi in Israel Trump wants to upgrade his plane AF1. Note Trumpwants after he leaves power for plane to belong to his library.. Trump was so furious at the bombing at Qatar that he forced Bibi to stop from pursuing all the goals that were supposedly crucial to Israel. No exile of Hamas they can stay in Gaza.
ReplyDeleteThe bombing of Qatar was the end of the war-Trump ensured that.